The Pageant File’s original vision was always to highlight the contestants and local titleholders who don’t advance to Miss America. After all, there is only one Miss America! Local titleholders are the heart of the Organization, and we rely on you to keep the heart beating. These lovely ladies competed for a local title and may not have walked away with the crown, but are still making an impact in their respective communities.

This list will be updated as more information is released.

Adirondack/Thousand Islands

(No runners up awarded)

Buffalo

1st Runner Up: Nicole Golias

2nd Runner Up: Jamie Hegerty

3rd Runner Up: Madison Hanel

Finger Lakes/Upstate New York

1st Runner Up: Serena Exatus

Five Boroughs/City of New York/Broadway

1st Runner Up: Bria Stone

Fulton County/Montgomery County

1st Runner Up: Chelsea Cirillo

2nd Runner Up: Alexis Houser

3rd Runner Up: Alexis Conti

Greater New York/Gotham

1st Runner Up: Sydney Park*

Queens/Manhattan

1st Runner Up: Mallory Strom

Staten Island/Richmond County

1st Runner Up: Alexa Moley

Downstate Open

1st Runner Up: Catherine Costagliola

 

*Asterics indicates runner up went on to win a subsequent title